Employment – Claims – Overseas Worker
In the case Saggar v Ministry of Defence [2005], it was held that an overseas based employee of a British business, who was a UK resident when recruited or at any time during the course of the employee's employment, is entitled to bring a discrimination claim in the UK. The claim can be brought even if the employee did no further work in Britain after the move overseas.
After 16 years at a Ministry of Defence base in Britain, Lieutenant Colonel Surinder Nath Saggar was permanently stationed in Cyprus from 1998 and was still there when he made a claim for race discrimination.
The Employment Tribunal decided that Lieutenant Saggar worked wholly outside Britain and could not file a race discrimination claim in Britain. He appealed against this decision to the Employment Appeals Tribunal ("EAT").
The EAT dismissed the appeal and held that:-
▪ In order for Lieutenant Saggar's claim to succeed, the EAT would have to look at the whole of his employment from 1982 onwards, and that would be "absurd";
▪ The EAT was bound by the decision of the Court of Appeal in the case of Carver v Saudi Arabian Airlines [1999] where for the purposes of establishing whether or not a tribunal has jurisdiction to hear a claim, it is necessary to consider whether, at the time of the alleged discrimination, the claimant was wholly or mainly working in Great Britain;
▪ Accordingly, at the time of the alleged discrimination, Lieutenant Saggar worked wholly in Cyprus.
The case went to the Court of Appeal and it was decided that: -
▪ The relevant period for determining whether a claimant worked wholly or mainly outside Great Britain is the whole period of employment;
▪ This approach was supported by the wording in s 8(1) of the Race Relations Act 1976; and
▪ This decision applied equally to all employees even though a person serving in the Armed Forces is not an employee as there is no contract of service.
The matter was remitted to a different tribunal to determine the issue of jurisdiction in accordance with the Court of Appeal's judgment.
Comment: This is a significant decision in favour of employees. This means that in many cases where employees are posted abroad they are entitled to bring employment claims in the UK. In practice, as well as complying with the rules of the country where employees are working, it would be sensible for employers to apply English employment law standards as well. Please contact us for more information: enquiries@rtcoopers.com
© RT COOPERS, 2005. This Briefing Note does not provide a comprehensive or complete statement of the law relating to the issues discussed nor does it constitute legal advice. It is intended only to highlight general issues. Specialist legal advice should always be sought in relation to particular circumstances.
Full service commercial law firm based in the City of London specialising in Employment Law, Employment Lawyers, Dismissals, Redundancies, Suspensions, Grievance and Disciplinary Procedures, Workplace Disuptes, Wrongful Dismissals, Breach of Contract, Business Secrets/Confidential Information, Contract Disputes, Drafting and Advising on Compromise Agreements, Drafting and Advising on Employment Contracts or Terms of Employment, Drafting and Advising on Staff Handbook and other Policy Documents, Employment Tribunal Claims, Employment Termination, Employee Benefits and Incentives, Equal Pay Disputes, Restructuring and Re-organisations, Senior Executive Appointments and Service Agreements, Sex Discrimination, Sexual Harassment, Sexual Orientation Issues, TUPE Transfers
If you have an employment question, please contact Rosanna at enquiries@rtcoopers.com. We have a number of employment legal uodates on our website at: http://www.rtcoopers.com/practice_employment.php
Employment Articles:
Gracefully Accepting Feedback a Key Employment Skill
With the long-term trend of protecting employees' individual self esteem added to an overriding concern over expensive employee lawsuits, accountability is more a buzzword than a way of life at most companies.This is a state of mind that has existed since the 1960s, so the average employee has never received real quality negative feedback -- the kind of feedback that might help startle him or her out of career-dashing behavior and toward a more lucrative and successful work life.
Colorado Health Insurance Expert Says There May be Better Alternatives to COBRA After Losing Employment
An individual health insurance policy may be a better alternative than electing COBRA coverage, according to Colorado health insurance expert Michael Horvat, founder of Healthquotes.com. Under COBRA, the former employee is responsible for up to 102% of the premium, whereas they likely paid only a fraction of the premium as an active employee. Care should be taken to choose the best individual policy given the former employee's unique situation.
Good Lawyers Equals Great Employment Deals
Have you been fired for no cause at all? Been working overtime yet underpaid? Been harassed by your boss?
Nursing Employment Opportunities
There has been a dramatic increase in nursing employment opportunities around the world in recent years, which is great news for qualified and experienced nurses worldwide. Once you understand the reason for the increase in nursing vacancies you will understand that this is a long term opportunity that nurses can take advantage of to boost their careers and life experiences.
The Need for Employment Background Checks
Depending on your state and what type of business you are in, employee background checks may or may not be mandated by law. In businesses that deal with children or seniors, Federal law requires background checks on all employees and/or volunteers. The reasons should be obvious: the Federal government wants to ensure that those served are safe from hard and employers need to safeguard themselves against negligent lawsuits.
Working Abroad - Employment Advice In Spain
Jobs and employment on the Costa BlancaThe Council of Europe regulations forced Spain to end all restrictions on the free
circulation of European Union workers as of January 1st, 1992 - which means that
all EU citizens can work in Spain under the same conditions as Spaniards complete
with employment contracts and employers contributions into the Spanish Social
Security system on your behalf, giving both yourself and your dependants, access to
the Spanish National Health Service. These rights extend even to family members
who are non EU nationals.
Wal-Mart Jobs: Drive Trucks for Wal-Mart for Wal-Mart Employment Benefits
Wal-Mart Stores, a private carrier, wants to hire safe truckers for their private fleet. They offer good, stable work to hard workers.
Northeast Technical Institute Partners with Synernet, Inc. to Offer its Graduates Exclusive Employment Opportunities
Northeast Technical Institute, a leader in short term health care training, announced its partnership with Synernet, Inc., a Portland, ME company that provides innovative and effective cost saving solutions to the health care industry.
Miami Based Verification Bureau Launches SUPRA, a New Solution to Verify Employment
By the name of SUPRA, Verification Bureau launches this electronic tool, with the support of fraud experts, it will verify all information regarding employment provided to a lender or banker, information that may be needed for numerous transactions.
Self-Employment Tax Deductions
Being your own boss can be a richly rewarding experience, but many people put it off because they fear facing a complex tax system. In reality, the tax process for self-employed individuals can be fairly simple, and offers its own set of rewards.
nowHIRE.com and Edge Information Management Provide Integrated ATS and Pre-Employment Services
Companies collaborate to seamlessly integrate background and drug testing services into the recruitment and hiring processes.
The Advantages Of Temporary Airline Employment
Graduates in the United Kingdom often seek out long term positions right after their university days. Indeed, the promise of higher education is that permanent positions and career options are readily available from the first day after graduation. However, many airlines and other aviation companies are turning toward temporary and seasonal positions in order to firm up their financial bottom line. Ticket agents, mechanics, and facilities professionals are among the workers who are often hired during the winter and summer holiday season to ensure flights get off the ground on time. However, airlines aren?t the only ones to gain advantage from temporary airline employment. Graduates should seek project airline work for a variety of reasons.
The MedZilla Report: April 2008 Employment Outlook for Biotech/Pharma/Health
Though the U.S. economic picture seems to grow more bleak by the day, the health care industry is one that has shown consistent job growth for the past year.
Employment Law, Part I
Just how serious is employment law to the small businessperson? Very serious and let me tell you a true story; a horror story, which will make you think about just how serious these issues can be. In San Antonio TX one of our wash trucks was driving down the road and a border Patrol Officer passed them.
Finding Employment For Medical Coders
The opportunities for medical coding jobs are extremely varied. Nevertheless the majority of them lead back to one place - a medical coding job with a medical clinic or hospital.